Advertisement
Ad slot
Why Mars Is Not Ready for Humans 6:06

Why Mars Is Not Ready for Humans

StarTalk Plus · May 9, 2026
Open on YouTube
Transcript ~1246 words · 6:06
0:00
Let's explore some of the scenarios that
0:02
are going to be potentially the reality
0:05
of us as a human race.
0:06
>> Let's go right on down the list. Go
0:08
>> the laundry list. Um, okay. Well, let's
0:10
look at Mars in 2050.
0:11
>> Oh, yeah.
0:12
>> How how are we saying maybe, maybe not?
Advertisement
Ad slot
0:15
You're kidding me. Oh, that's definitely
0:16
going to happen.
0:17
>> Yeah. Elon Musk, he has said he wants to
0:19
put a million people on Mars by 2050 to
0:23
have a self- sustaining civilization
0:24
that will survive there even if you know
0:28
the rockets from Earth stop coming
0:29
because there's been an asteroid strike
0:30
or nuclear war or something here.
0:32
>> That's definitely not happening. There
Advertisement
Ad slot
0:35
are a lot of reasons why that's not
0:37
happening. Getting anyone to Mars by
0:40
2050 and bringing them back alive or
0:42
just having them live there for a while,
0:44
that would be incredibly difficult. The
0:46
challenges just to put boots on Mars the
0:49
way that we did on the moon are
0:51
enormous, right? Just learning how to
0:53
keep someone alive in deep space that
0:56
far away from Earth for as long as it
0:58
takes to get to Mars, stay on Mars, come
1:01
back. We do not know how to do that yet.
1:03
>> Chuck, that's the problem. They want to
1:04
put boots on Mars instead of sneakers on
1:06
Mars. [laughter] Sneaker contract,
1:08
you'll pay the whole way.
1:09
>> Nike would have put Nike would have been
1:10
there by now. [laughter]
1:12
>> They just do it. Yeah. Exactly.
1:15
>> Excellent.
1:16
>> Just do it.
1:17
>> It ain't about boots. [laughter] It is
1:18
about sneakers.
1:20
>> I mean, so
1:21
>> what are the biggest challenges of going
1:23
that far into space? Is it radiation or
1:25
>> Yeah, there's radiation. And that's not
1:27
just when you're in space, it's also
1:28
when you're on Mars, right? You know,
1:30
the two things that primarily protect us
1:33
from radiation here on Earth are our,
1:35
you know, the Earth's magnetic field and
1:38
the thick atmosphere that Earth has.
1:40
Mars doesn't have either of those
1:41
things. So when you're on the surface of
1:42
Mars, you're getting pretty much the
1:43
same radiation dose that you do like out
1:45
in space. And that's not good, right?
1:48
You know, like the thing that I tell
1:49
people is the movie The Martian is
1:51
science fiction. One of the things
1:53
that's science fiction about it is if
1:54
Mark Wattney really, you know, had to do
1:56
all the stuff that he did in that movie,
1:58
he'd come home and he'd be dead of
2:00
cancer in a couple of years because he
2:01
had too much radiation exposure hanging
2:03
out on Mars.
2:05
>> What about the ISS? If Scott Kelly could
2:07
stay up there for a year,
2:07
>> one of the twins, one stayed on Earth
2:09
and one, right? Why couldn't you just
2:12
extend that for whatever time necessary
2:15
to go to Mars? Even if it's not to live
2:18
there, if it's just to go there and dig
2:20
a hole and come back,
2:22
>> right? So, there's a couple of things.
2:23
First of all, on the ISS, they're still
2:26
in the Earth's magnetic field. They
2:27
still have a bunch of the shielding.
2:29
>> Oh, wait. And what's that called, Neil?
2:30
Wait, the field that goes all the way
2:32
out like that.
2:33
>> Oh, yeah.
2:33
>> Oh, it's called the Oh, magnetic field.
2:35
>> No, it's not the magnetic. It's the
2:38
magnetosphere.
2:39
>> Yeah. Yeah. Think of X-Men. Yes, the
2:40
magnetosphere. Go ahead.
2:43
>> Yeah, exactly. It is like the X-Men.
2:44
Yeah, they've still got that protection.
2:46
Also, if something goes wrong on the
2:49
ISS, they'll be back on the surface of
2:51
the Earth in a matter of hours. Like,
2:52
they can just abort and come back home,
2:54
right?
2:54
>> Yeah. At most, I mean, you can you come
2:57
out, you you're down within a half hour.
2:59
>> Exactly. Yeah. The hours is you want to
3:01
line up so you don't land in the middle
3:02
of sharks,
3:03
>> right? [laughter] Exactly. Yeah. Yeah.
3:05
Yeah. Yeah. So like you can get out easy
3:07
and you can also have a real time
3:09
conversation with people on the ground
3:11
because they're you know they're not
3:12
that high up and so the speed of light
3:15
delay with the conversation doesn't
3:17
matter
3:19
>> on Mars you know it's a minimum of
3:21
something like I think 8 minutes each
3:23
way and a maximum of something like 15
3:26
or 20 one way and so if you send out a
3:29
message you are waiting at least 15 20
3:32
minutes to get a message back maybe more
3:34
like
3:35
Yeah.
3:35
>> You better not be like, "So, how's it
3:37
going?" Over.
3:38
>> Yeah.
3:39
>> Yeah. Put some content in there.
3:40
[laughter]
3:42
>> Or or watch out for the cliff.
3:44
>> Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And the other thing
3:46
is like if you have a problem on the
3:48
surface of Mars and you want to come
3:49
back, that's going to take you uh at
3:52
least 9 months, maybe more if you happen
3:55
to be near a launch window where you
3:57
know the Earth and the and Mars are like
3:59
in the right
4:00
>> positions. If you're not near launch
4:02
window, it could be well over a year
4:04
before you can come home. And
4:06
>> yeah, a full up roundtrip mission to
4:07
Mars with ideal launch and return
4:11
parameters is multiple years.
4:12
>> Yeah.
4:13
>> Right.
4:14
>> But you can get to the moon and back in
4:15
a week. Yep. In like a in a news cycle.
4:17
Yep.
4:18
>> Right.
4:18
>> So if we overcome the logistics of
4:20
getting from Earth to Mars Yeah. If big
4:22
big if, where are they going to live?
4:24
Cuz they're not going to go out there
4:25
and start building.
4:27
>> Yeah. And then
4:28
>> why don't you just uh build a little
4:29
sort of half underground thing that
4:31
shields you from Sure.
4:34
>> Yeah. Well, so then you have other
4:35
problems, right? You know, there's no
4:37
air. You got to bring in oxygen or, you
4:40
know, do some sort of reaction to make
4:41
oxygen on the surface, which yeah, you
4:43
can do that, but it's not the easiest
4:44
thing. Uh you got to bring in all your
4:46
food. Can't grow it there. The Martian
4:49
surface, the dirt on Mars is filled with
4:52
toxic chemicals. You're going to have a
4:54
hard time getting it out of stuff cuz
4:55
it's very fine. It's not It's going to
4:57
be that's going to be here on Earth
4:58
soon, too. So, [laughter] chemical I
5:00
mean I mean let's be for real.
5:02
>> Yeah,
5:03
>> but we know you can grow poop potatoes
5:05
on.
5:06
>> Yes,
5:06
>> we know that.
5:08
>> Yes, exactly. Yeah, there was a proof of
5:10
concept in the movie The Martian.
5:11
[laughter]
5:12
>> Duh.
5:12
>> No, but but actually it's it's funny
5:14
though. The guy who wrote the book uh
5:15
what's his name? Andy.
5:17
>> Andy Weir. Yeah.
5:18
>> In fact, we had him on the show. Yeah.
5:19
He's in our archives. He has said that
5:22
you know the discovery of these
5:23
particular poisonous compounds in the
5:26
Martian surface uh called perchlorates
5:28
he didn't know about that when he wrote
5:30
the book because it wasn't widely known
5:32
and so now we know if you tried to you
5:34
know farm poop potatoes on Mars they'd
5:36
be poisonous.
5:38
>> Yeah.
5:38
>> So that's the unknown unknown.
5:40
>> Yeah. Exactly. Right. [music]
5:53
>> [music]
5:58
[music]
6:04
[music]
— end of transcript —
Advertisement
Ad slot

Trending Transcripts

Disclaimer: This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by YouTube or Google LLC. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Transcripts are sourced from publicly available captions on YouTube and remain the property of their original creators.